This is ForecastNest’s 1 day forecast for SPY, created 2026-09-17 14:20 UTC. The window closed 2026-09-18 14:20 UTC, when SPY closed at $759.37, down 0.3% from $761.48 when the forecast was made. It traded between $758.75 and $763.57 along the way (-0.4% to +0.3%).
Prediction window: Equity / ETF 1D: the stored target below is authoritative; it may be a session close or an intraday instant.
Prediction time: 2026-09-17 14:20 UTC (9/17/2026, 10:20:45 AM EDT).
Valid until: 2026-09-18 14:20 UTC (9/18/2026, 10:20:45 AM EDT). Target session: 2026-09-18 (New York); During session. Lead time to expiry: 24 elapsed hours. Timing: Regular session. Based on stored prediction time, not verified model execution time.
Want to forecast SPY -- or any other stock or ETF -- with your own model and see how it stacks up against these? Create your own AI model benchmark on ForecastNest.
2 of the 5 models called a direction, and 2 of those calls were right. Each model is also asked to find the price it was forecasting from when it answers, shown as the dashed line inside its box in the picture below. Every model found it accurately.
Below are the details.
| Model | Range | Move | Confidence | Price it found | Score | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GPT-5.6 Sol | $754.00–$767.50 | -0.9% to +0.8% | 56% | $761.22 | 54.2 | no call |
| Claude Opus 5 | $754.20–$771.00 | -1.2% to +1.0% | 50% | $763.00 | 53.7 | no call |
| Muse Spark 1.1 | $746.00–$760.00 | -1.1% to +0.8% | 53% | $754.20 | 80.6 | right |
| DeepSeek V3 | $745.00–$762.00 | -1.2% to +1.1% | 60% | $754.05 | 54.1 | no call |
| Gemini 1.5 Pro | $753.00–$768.00 | -1.1% to +0.9% | 65% | $761.49 | 81.5 | right |
How these models have done on SPY over 1 day
This forecast is settled and is included in the statistics below. The remaining records are forecasts created before 2026-09-17 14:20 UTC. Only settled directional calls count toward accuracy.
| Model | Asked | Still open | No call | Called up | Called down | Right |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claude Sonnet 5 | 1 | — | 0 | — | 1 · 1 right | 100% (1/1) |
| GPT-5.6 Sol | 9 | — | 2 | — | 7 · 6 right | 86% (6/7) |
| Muse Spark 1.1 | 6 | — | 3 | — | 3 · 2 right | 67% (2/3) |
| Gemini 1.5 Pro | 12 | — | 9 | — | 3 · 2 right | 67% (2/3) |
| Claude Opus 5 | 12 | — | 5 | — | 7 · 4 right | 57% (4/7) |
| GPT-6 | 3 | — | 0 | — | 3 · 1 right | 33% (1/3) |
| DeepSeek V3 | 12 | — | 5 | 3 · 0 right | 4 · 1 right | 14% (1/7) |
| Grok 4.5 | 9 | — | 9 | — | — | — |
| Kimi | 1 | — | 1 | — | — | — |
Every published SPY forecast over 1 day before this question was asked, on 2026-09-17 14:20 UTC, plus this settled forecast. Forecasts created after this question are excluded. Results reflect the settlements available when this article is generated. A day-ahead call and a week-ahead one are counted separately — they are different questions. Only settled forecasts are graded, so open + no call + up + down adds up to asked. “No call” is a range too centred on the price to be pointing anywhere. Accuracy counts only forecasts that have settled, and the count behind it is shown beside it — a single right call is not a 100% record.
What each model said
GPT-5.6 Sol
Result: no call
View full reasoning
(1) What I found: Investing.com showed SPY at $761.22 on September 17, with an intraday range of $761.09-$763.41 and a previous regular-session close of $754.05. Reuters reported that the S&P 500 opened 1.05% higher at 7,631.44 as lower oil prices and relief following the Federal Reserve decision lifted equities. The fact that SPY was around $761.22 after opening near $763.40 indicates that part of the initial gap had already faded by the time of this forecast. Sources: [https://ca.investing.com/etfs/spdr-s-p-500](https://ca.investing.com/etfs/spdr-s-p-500) and [https://www.reuters.com/business/wall-st-futures-rise-fed-rate-hike-lifts-long-standing-overhang-2026-09-17/
(2)](https://www.reuters.com/business/wall-st-futures-rise-fed-rate-hike-lifts-long-standing-overhang-2026-09-17/
%282%29) Market regime: The immediate regime is a relief rebound inside a more difficult rate-and-inflation environment. The Federal Reserve raised its target range by 25 basis points to 3.75%-4.00% and signaled that additional tightening remains possible, while the prior sessions were pressured by the 10-year Treasury yield moving around or above 5%. Lower crude prices are providing temporary relief, but the stronger dollar, high real borrowing costs and a still-hawkish Fed argue against treating today's gap higher as a clean trend reversal. Sources: [https://www.reuters.com/markets/wealth/fed-builds-credibility-hawkish-turn-leaves-investors-edgy-2026-09-17/](https://www.reuters.com/markets/wealth/fed-builds-credibility-hawkish-turn-leaves-investors-edgy-2026-09-17/) and [https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/oil-prices-extend-losses-fears-middle-east-supply-disruptions-ease-2026-09-17/
(3)](https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/oil-prices-extend-losses-fears-middle-east-supply-disruptions-ease-2026-09-17/
%283%29) Price range: I use $754.00-$767.50 for the next one-day window. The lower bound is approximately the September 16 close and allows for a full retracement of today's relief gap if yields or oil reverse higher. The upper bound sits above today's opening area but below the September 11 SPY close of $764.29 plus a moderate extension, reflecting the possibility that the rebound broadens without assuming an immediate return to the late-August highs near $775-$779. Recent SPY sessions have commonly moved several dollars intraday, and September 16 alone ranged from $749.60 to $761.67. Source: [https://ca.investing.com/etfs/spdr-s-p-500-historical-data
(4)](https://ca.investing.com/etfs/spdr-s-p-500-historical-data
%284%29) Catalysts inside the window: The key variables are Treasury yields, crude oil and continued interpretation of the Fed's first rate increase since 2023. Weekly U.S. jobless claims unexpectedly fell to 196,000 versus an expected 208,000, reinforcing the view that the labor market remains resilient and giving the Fed less reason to reverse its hawkish stance. Oil fell roughly 3% as supply-disruption fears eased, which is currently supportive for equities; a reversal in that move would quickly restore inflation concerns. Sources: [https://www.reuters.com/business/us-weekly-jobless-claims-unexpectedly-fall-2026-09-17/](https://www.reuters.com/business/us-weekly-jobless-claims-unexpectedly-fall-2026-09-17/) and [https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/oil-prices-extend-losses-fears-middle-east-supply-disruptions-ease-2026-09-17/
(5)](https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/oil-prices-extend-losses-fears-middle-east-supply-disruptions-ease-2026-09-17/
%285%29) Strongest counter-argument: The bullish case is that the Fed removed a major uncertainty, oil continues falling, long-term yields stabilize and technology leadership turns today's gap into a sustained rebound. A durable move above roughly $764-$765 with broad participation would weaken my near-term cautious view and make the upper part of the range more likely. The bearish counterpoint is that today's opening surge has already begun fading; a move back through roughly $758 and especially toward the prior $754.05 close would suggest the relief rally is failing rather than beginning a new advance. Sources: [https://ca.investing.com/etfs/spdr-s-p-500](https://ca.investing.com/etfs/spdr-s-p-500) and [https://www.reuters.com/business/wall-st-futures-rise-fed-rate-hike-lifts-long-standing-overhang-2026-09-17/
(6)](https://www.reuters.com/business/wall-st-futures-rise-fed-rate-hike-lifts-long-standing-overhang-2026-09-17/
%286%29) Confidence: 56% reflects conflicting signals. Lower oil, a strong opening rebound and broad technology strength are constructive, but the intraday fade, a newly higher policy rate, resilient labor data and elevated Treasury yields limit directional conviction. Over a single session these forces can easily offset one another, so the 1-day signal is NEUTRAL rather than forcing a bullish or bearish call; the longer 7-day and 30-day signals remain mildly bearish because tighter financial conditions are still the dominant macro headwind.
Claude Opus 5
Result: no call
View full reasoning
(1) What I found, and where, with an unresolved discrepancy I want to flag: Benzinga's inline ticker in an article timestamped 17 September 8:43 a.m. ET shows SPY at 763.29, QQQ at 715.87 up 1.58%, DIA at 521.21 up 1.16%, GLD at 401.48 up 2.49% and BTC at 76,818.60 (benzinga.com/markets/equities/26/09/61834756/). That BTC figure matches what I independently verified this morning from four crypto sources, which is my main reason for trusting the snapshot. Yahoo's SPY history header shows a 16 September close of 760.48, up 6.35 or 0.84%, but CNBC reports the S&P 500 fell 0.45% on Wednesday to close at 7,551.81, and those two cannot both be right. Working from SPY's confirmed 15 September close of 758.75 and CNBC's index move gives roughly 755 for Wednesday instead. I anchor at $763.00 and note that if the Yahoo header is the stale one, my anchor may sit about one percent high.
(2) Market regime: a post-event relief tape with the macro pressure genuinely easing at the margin. The Fed raised rates 25 basis points to 3.75%-4.00% unanimously on Wednesday with a hawkish dot plot, and Warsh's remarks knocked the Dow 631 points lower into the close. Overnight the picture improved: Bloomberg reports Treasuries paring losses with the 2-year down one basis point to 4.72% and the 10-year and 30-year each about two basis points lower, and TipRanks headlines futures rallying as oil retreats. Jobless claims for the week ending 12 September fell to 196,000, confirming labour strength, while August housing starts dropped 2.6% to a 1.275 million annualised rate. So the two forces that drove the whole week, a relentless crude advance and a long end pushing above 5%, are both backing off for the first time.
(3) Price range: anchored at $763.00 and placed close to symmetric on purpose, because my one-day read is a genuine abstention rather than an undecided one. Post-event volatility typically contracts once the uncertainty premium is released, so I am using a daily sigma near 0.85%, giving about -1.15% to +1.05%, or $754.20 to $771.00. The levels: Monday's $757.93 low and the $755 area mark the floor the market defended all week, while the record close of $777.88 from 13 August sits well above. The near-symmetry reflects that roughly a percent of relief is already in the price before this window opens, so continuation rather than the event itself is what upside now requires.
(4) Catalysts inside the window: the notable one is Friday 18 September, quarterly triple witching, when index options, index futures and single-stock options all expire alongside the quarterly index rebalance. That falls inside a window closing at 10:20 ET Friday and reliably produces heavy volume and pinning behaviour that is two-sided rather than directional. Thursday's data is already out. Goldman Sachs expects another 25 basis point hike in October, per TipRanks, so Fed-speak in the coming sessions carries weight. Middle East headlines remain live, with Iran's parliament speaker making public remarks on the conflict this morning.
(5) Strongest counter-argument, running both ways, which is why I abstain: the bullish case is that the two genuine pressures have eased simultaneously, the labour market is strong at 196,000 claims, and gold up 2.49% alongside equities suggests liquidity returning rather than fear. The bearish case is that nothing in the policy path improved, with the dot plot projecting another hike this year, no cuts in 2027 and inflation above target until 2029, and Goldman already pencilling in October. A relief bounce after a hawkish surprise is frequently retraced within days. A close above $771 would argue the relief has legs; a failure to hold $757 would say Wednesday's verdict stands.
(6) Why 50%: the lowest I have given, and the anchor is the reason rather than the analysis. I have two sources that disagree by roughly one percent about where SPY closed on Wednesday, and I could not resolve it from a third. That uncertainty flows directly into both the reported price and the range bounds. On top of that, the directional evidence is balanced by construction: the drivers improved, the policy path did not, and most of today's move printed before the window opened. Fifty percent is what an honest abstention on direction plus a compromised anchor deserves.
Muse Spark 1.1
Result: right
View full reasoning
(1) What you found, and where: MacroTrends reports latest close Sep 16 2026 $754.20 all-time high $777.88 Aug 13 2026. Calamos data Sep 16 3:16 PM CDT shows ref asset $754.05 -0.46% vs $767.05 Sep 1. INDmoney SPY share today $754.05. Cestrian Capital Sep 16 notes SPY hugging 50-day SMA $759 closed Tuesday $757.39 couple dollars under and $759 this morning, levels .5 retrace $754 and .618 $748. StatMuse notes closing Thursdays $754.81 last Wednesday up 2996.8% and latest $748.20. Cambridge Currencies Sep 16 confirms Fed voted 12-0 raise to 3.75%-4.00% 2pm ET first hike since July 2023.
(2) The current market regime as you read it: Post-hike digestion. 5-day TSPY -1.45% per Finnhub, SPY -1.69% Sep 1-16 per Calamos. Futures noted Sep 16 rose then oil edged lower per Morningstar with 91% hike odds per LSEG. After realized hike, market testing 50-day $759 support. Cestrian $771 pivot to $870 target vs $754 $748 retraces. Regime favors slight downside if Warsh hawkish and real yields up.
(3) Price range justification, with the levels and volatility you are using: Anchored to $754.20 Sep 16 close per MacroTrends and $754.05 Calamos. Using intraday $748.20 latest per StatMuse and $754-748 retraces per Cestrian and $759 50-day. Daily vol ~1% = ~$7.5. Lower $746 captures -1.1% below $754 toward $748 .618 retrace if hawkish, upper $760 captures +0.77% back to 50-day $759 $760. Slight downside skew because hike delivered and UMich sentiment plunge with inflation outlook soaring per CoinDesk Sep 17.
(4) Scheduled or likely catalysts inside the window: Window Sep 17 14:20 UTC 24h covers Sep 17-18 post-FOMC trading, no Fed speakers due to blackout lift but Warsh follow-through per FXStreet Sep 16. No major SPY earnings, focus on Treasury yields and bitcoin $76,700-$77,400 post-Fed per CoinDesk. Oil eases but bond market pressure per CoinDesk.
(5) The strongest counter-argument, and what would invalidate your call: Bull case: if Fed hike seen as one-and-done with 9 of 18 projections calling for hike in 2026 per Morningstar Canada, market could reclaim $759 50-day and $771 pivot toward $770 per Cestrian. Invalidation: close above $762 with yields falling would negate mild bearish; close below $745 would extend.
(6) Why your confidence is the number it is: Confidence 53% reflects live close $754.20 dated Sep 16 after window start with corroborating $754.05 Calamos and $754.81 Thursday reference per StatMuse, but post-hike direction noisy. Labeling live because quote is Sep 16 close after baseline timestamp.
DeepSeek V3
Result: no call
View full reasoning
(1) What I found: SPY closed Wednesday September 16 at $754.05, down 0.44% after the Fed delivered its first rate hike since 2023 (forum.finanzen.ch; RTHK). The ETF traded down to $749.60 during Wednesday's session before recovering, and spent the overnight session climbing back through $756.15 and $759.13 to $760.48 (TradingView). E-mini S&P 500 futures traded at 7,665.25 in Asian hours on September 17, up 0.55% from the previous session, and the 10-year Treasury yield eased to 4.998% from roughly 5.01% (Yonhap Infomax).
(2) Market regime: The FOMC raised rates 25bp to 3.75%-4.00% in a unanimous 12-0 vote. Chair Warsh said inflation 'is too high and has been for too long,' and the dot plot showed one more hike before year-end, with no cuts projected for 2027 (Benzinga). The S&P 500 fell 0.5% Wednesday, the Dow dropped 631 points, and the energy sector lost 3% as WTI crude settled down 3.2% (RTHK). The 10-year yield closed Wednesday at roughly 5.01%, its highest since 2007 (Benzinga). BofA's Savita Subramanian warned stocks are 'overdue for a pullback,' and Ed Yardeni cut his year-end S&P 500 target to 7,900 from 8,400, citing higher yields compressing multiples (Bloomberg, Benzinga).
(3) Price range: I am using the $749.60 Wednesday low as the structural floor and the $762.57 shelf as immediate resistance (TradingView). The next resistance above is $765.52, the level that has capped the range three times. Support below $749.60 sits at $745-$747. SPY is trading below its 50-day moving average, and the RSI and PPO are showing slowing momentum (StockCharts). With a bearish tilt, I skew the range downward: $745.00 captures a decisive break below the $749.60 floor toward the June-July range, while $762.00 represents a short-covering bounce through the $762.57 shelf if Treasury yields continue to ease and the Fed's hawkish message is digested.
(4) Catalysts: U.S. initial jobless claims (206.5K expected), Philadelphia Fed Business Index (32.1 expected), housing starts, building permits, and pending home sales are all scheduled for September 17 (XTB). The Bank of England rate decision at 13:00 UTC is expected to hold at 3.75%. No major Fed speakers are scheduled. The dominant theme is post-Fed positioning and whether the market treats the hike as a one-off or the start of a cycle.
(5) Counter-argument: The strongest bullish case is that $749.60 was swept and bought hard, the 4H chart showed a flush and reversal pattern with the heaviest participation reading in weeks, and futures are already rebounding (TradingView, Yonhap Infomax). If SPY reclaims $762.57 with volume, the entire break unwinds and $765.52 comes back into play. A clean break below $749.60 would confirm the bearish structure and open $745.
(6) Confidence: 60% reflects a clear bearish post-Fed tilt but genuine uncertainty around whether the sell-off is exhausted. The market has already priced the hike, and the overnight recovery from $749.60 shows buyers are active at the lows. However, SPY remains below its 50-day MA, momentum is slowing, and the hawkish dot plot keeps a lid on upside. A single day is a short window and the market is still digesting the Fed's message.
Gemini 1.5 Pro
Result: right
View full reasoning
(1) Data sources: I retrieved live market data showing SPY trading near $761.49 as of 14:20 UTC on September 17, 2026. I also reviewed post-FOMC coverage from BNN Bloomberg regarding Fed Chair Kevin Warsh's rate hike yesterday, alongside initial jobless claims data from GuruFocus.
(2) Market regime: The market is experiencing a resilient post-FOMC relief bounce. While the Federal Reserve delivered a 25-basis-point rate hike yesterday to a 3.75%-4.00% target range to combat sticky inflation, stronger-than-expected initial jobless claims this morning (dropping to 196,000) have eased recessionary fears, allowing equities to shrug off the hawkish monetary policy shift for now.
(3) Price range justification: I project a 24-hour range of $753.00-$768.00. Options pricing indicates an expected move of approximately ±$6.23 for the session. With SPY pushing above the $760 level, the near-term momentum is bullish, targeting the $765 to $768 resistance zone, while $753 to $754 serves as a strong technical floor near the previous session's close.
(4) Scheduled or likely catalysts inside the window: With the highly anticipated FOMC rate decision and press conference now in the rearview mirror and today's labor data already published, the next 24 hours will be driven by institutional repositioning and the digestion of the Fed's new economic projections.
(5) The strongest counter-argument: The primary risk to this bullish relief bounce is delayed realization of the Fed's hawkish reality. With the 2-year Treasury yield rising to 4.74%, higher borrowing costs could quickly stifle the equity rally, triggering a mean-reversion selloff back below the $754 level.
(6) Why your confidence is the number it is: My confidence is 65%. While today's strong labor data provides a clear catalyst for a short-term relief rally, the overarching headwind of a newly hawkish central bank introduces significant whipsaw risk in the immediate post-Fed trading window. For more context on the macroeconomic factors influencing these market conditions, you can watch [Chairman Kevin Warsh's Fed rate hike remarks](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nkmrr7P5gW4), which provides direct insights into the central bank's policy stance.
Read this comparison on ForecastNest, where it stays up to date if a score is ever recomputed.
Published automatically when this question settled, from shared research a member chose to make public. Content on ForecastNest Insights is for research, educational and informational purposes only. Nothing here is financial, investment, legal or tax advice, and nothing here is a recommendation to buy or sell anything.